JJ 07/70: Wayne Shorter – Super Nova

A review by Mark Gardner, first published in Jazz Journal July 1970

On this weird ‘space music’ record Shorter plays only soprano saxophone which he has been concentrating on of late. He seems to have patterned his playing after that of John Coltrane, although his tone is not quite so dry as was Trane’s.

Nothing on the album really turns me around and it is a far cry from Shorter’s splendid Adam’s Apple set. The emphasis on free playing may be ex­plained by what the liner note calls ‘a very loose date with no rehearsal’. Some aspects of the performances just don’t make sense. For instance the ‘play-as-we-please’ wild in­troduction and ending to Dindi bears no re­lationship at all to Maria Booker’s slow and emotional bossa (but not super) nova vocal.


Super Nova is one of those increasingly numerous sound storms that batter the ears these days while Swee-pea, a tribute to Strayhorn, of course, is a limpid, static theme that fails to get off the ground. Water Babies has a typical Coltrane type of atmosphere as in­deed does the rather boring Capricorn. Neither was I especially enlightened by the curious More Than Human, with its banjo-like accompaniment.

For this listener the LP is, as you will gather, largely baffling. Barry McRae, on the other hand, may have been able to offer a more useful evaluation of the proceedings. Herb Wong reckons ‘the Shorter album sets up movement for new directions with consum­mate power’. One wonders if the new direc­tions are the right directions. Let’s just say they’re not my bag and leave it at that.

Super Nova; Swee-Pea; Dindi (19 min) – Water Babies; Capricorn; More Than Human (18¾ min)
Wayne Shorter (sop); John McLaughlin, Sonny Sharrock, Walter Booker (gtr); Jack DeJohnette (dm/African thumb pno); Chick Corea (dm/vib); Moroslav Vitous (bs); Airto Moreira (perc); Maria Booker (vcl on Dindi only). NYC, 29/8 & 2/9/69.
(Blue Note BST 84332 47s 6d)


Jazz Journal articles by month

The Flying Horse Big Band: Florida Rays

The Flying Horse Big Band’s energy is contagious. I confess that I was not aware of the existence of the student band from the...

Obituary: Ginger Baker

The problem is that Ginger Baker rather early disappeared behind “Ginger Baker”, the flame-haired irascible who notoriously broke the nose of a documentary maker...

Shri: beyond the groove

One of the most enjoyable and inspiring gigs I've caught in some while came courtesy of the award-winning Shrikanth Sriram, better known as Shri....

Ronnie Scott’s 1959-69: Photographs By Freddy Warren

Facing a photograph of the saxophonist at the time of his most podgy and physically unattractive period is a quote from Ronnie Scott: “Stan...


I learned everything I know about Buddy Bolden from Hear Me Talkin’ To Ya, the one indispensable book about jazz from soup to nuts,...

JJ 08/89: Paul Bley / Paul Motian – Notes

This record represents some­thing of a seduction job. It offers two of the most melodic of play­ers using their instruments to really 'take' the...