Rob Clutton Trio: Counsel Of Primaries

In brief:
"The trio is wonderfully balanced, the soloists are fully exposed – it's beautifully honest playing, in the manner of Lee Konitz"

I’d admired bassist and composer Rob Clutton’s previous recording, the duo Offering with New York avant-gardist Tony Malaby (2019, also on Snailbongbong). It was aptly described by Downbeat as “expansive and sensitive in spirit”, and that seems a good description of the present album also, which features an all-Canadian trio of alto saxophone, bass and drums.

The two albums have a common compositional approach: several pieces began as deconstructions of improvised bass lines from Clutton’s archive of recordings. In both cases, there’s a richness and fluidity to the music-making that’s very engaging.


Clutton is a long-time and formidable presence on the Toronto jazz scene, which is a major one. He has a song-based project called the Cluttertones, but recordings have focused on more avant-garde material. On Counsel his very simpatico partners are Nick Fraser and Karen Ng, the latter a compelling, original voice on alto saxophone. Her playing isn’t as bluesy as Ornette Coleman’s, but it’s a sound that couldn’t have existed without the jazz revolution that Coleman wrought. Early influences – she explains by email – were Lee Konitz and Lester Young as well as Ornette, and she studied with the ICP (Instant Composer’s Pool). It figures that she’s a fan of cool players Steve Lacy, John Carter, Jimmy Giuffre, Julius Hemphill and Marion Brown.

The trio is wonderfully balanced, the soloists are fully exposed – it’s beautifully honest playing, in the manner of Lee Konitz.

The album begins with Strata, in which sax and drums are prominent; an insistent cymbal pulse interacts with free and tonally complex work from the saxophonist. Festival has an Ornette Coleman-ish ethos, with Fraser echoing the march feel of Ed Blackwell. In the dirge-like Sterling, saxophone and arco bass explore dark, broken phrases in a kind of lugubrious heterophony; percussion is subdued but gradually expands its role through the piece. The stately Old Nick, and the jaunty, bucolic Shelter that follows it, make a neat contrast – Ng’s soloing here is beautifully nuanced.

The 10 tracks add up to a very substantial, varied and rewarding musical experience.

Hear/buy Rob Clutton Trio: Counsel Of Primaries at

Strata; Festival; Sterling; Counsel of Primaries; Cloak; Hounds; Thing One; Old Nick; Shelter; Magnetic (66.31)
Karen Ng (as); Rob Clutton (b); Nick Fraser (d). Toronto, nd.
Snailbongbong Records SBB007

Latest audio reviews


More from this author


Jazz Journal articles by month


Lolly Allen: Coming Home

Ask any jazz enthusiast for the names of female vibes soloists and they will probably come up with Margie Hyams, maybe Terry Pollard and...

Obituary: Wally Fawkes

Bechet-style clarinettist and creator of the Daily Mail's Flook cartoon who played with Humphrey Lyttelton and ran Trog's jazz club in Chelsea

Bangers and clankers /1

Apart from Beryl Bryden, the banjo is the most unmusical thing in jazz. The Merseysippi Jazz Band was playing at the Sacramento Jazz Festival when...

Dreams In Double Time

Californian English prof discusses four non-native US jazz players, including himself, in the context of sociology, racism and politics

Billy Bang: Lucky Man

This film follows violinist Billy Bang as he returns to Vietnam in 2008, where he served as a young soldier 40 years earlier, and...

JJ 10/69: Jazz At The Film Theatre

Multimedia experiments in the arts, running rampant as they do nowadays, frequently pair rather strange bedfellows. Jazz-cum-film, a perfectly feasible and exciting form in...
"The trio is wonderfully balanced, the soloists are fully exposed – it's beautifully honest playing, in the manner of Lee Konitz"Rob Clutton Trio: Counsel Of Primaries