Advertisement
Advertisement

JJ 08/70: Nucleus – Elastic Rock

Fifty years ago Barry McRae deplored the adoption by jazz players of the "predictable pulse of rock with all its super­ficial vitality". First published in Jazz Journal August 1970

In this day of broadening musical tastes, I am sure that there are many readers who enjoy both the creativity of jazz and the explosive energy of the best in heavy pop. I suspect that this album will satisfy neither camp and, because of the proven talent of the players concerned, will be rated as a disappointment.

Marshall handles the varied styles required in exemplary manner, Carr has a shapely solo on Torrid as well as sharing a fine duet with Smith on Twisted and Clyne’s arco Striation offers a very good bass work­out.

Advertisement

Regrettably the rest is rather anonymous, with the refined, two part Crude Blues, in particular, failing to live up to its title. The ferocious Persephone and Earth Mother would come nearest to pleasing non-jazz readers, especially the latter with its insistent rock bass in support of Jenkin’s oboe.

Too often, however, we are faced with the fact that a jazz solo is no more successful with a rock rhythm section than it was with West Indian, Bossa Nova or Indian styles. It seems futile to reject the rhythmic tradition, so brilliantly extended in recent years by men like Elvin Jones or Milford Graves, for the predictable pulse of rock with all its super­ficial vitality.

Nucleus’ Elastic Rock as advertised in JJ August 1970

It may be that the more hip of the pop fans will buy this record and be won over by the work of men like Carr and Clyne. I suspect that only the most inquisitively minded jazz fans will bother.

Discography
1916; Elastic Rock; Striation; Taranki; Twisted Track; Crude Blues (Part 1); Crude Blues (Part 2); 1916—The Battle Of Boogaloo (21 min)— Torrid Zone; Stonescape; Earth Mother; Speak­ing For Myself, Personally, In My Opinion, I Think . . .; Persephone’s Jive (19¾ min)
lan Carr (tpt/fgl-h); Karl Jenkins (bari/oboe/pno/el-pno): Brian Smith (ten/sop/flt); Chris Spedding (gtr); Jeff Clyne (bs): John Marshall (dm). London, 12-1 3-1 5-21 /1/70.
(Vertigo 6360 008 42s 6d)

Latest audio reviews

Advertisement

More from this author

Advertisement

Jazz Journal articles by month

Advertisement

Ahmad Jamal: Emerald City Nights – Live At The Penthouse 1963-1964 

Previously unreleased radio tapes of the mercurial pianist and his freewheeling trio in Seattle are collected on two 180g LPs
Advertisement

On the Other Hand 06/20

Dave Gelly discovers the silver lining of epidemical house-arrest - rummaging among old records. For Art Themen, it's front doorstep serenades for the neighbours
Advertisement

Rosie Frater-Taylor: rolling up Benson, Mitchell and more

“I don’t like labels because labelling fights your urge to just make music the way you want to,” asserts fast-rising London singer-songwriter and guitarist...
Advertisement

Jim Marshall: Show Me The Picture: Images And Stories From A Photography Legend

Jim Marshall (1936-2010) is largely known for his images of the jazz greats and rock stars of the 60s and 70s. This book shows...
Advertisement

Oscar Peterson: Black + White

Film tribute to the pianist has valuable footage of OP and testimony from other musicians but doesn't convey his real significance
Advertisement

JJ 03/61: In My Opinion – Don Byas

Sixty years ago saxophonist Don Byas loved Basie, Ellington and Gillespie but was less keen on Stan Kenton, Eddie 'Lockjaw' Davis, and Buddy Tate's rhythm section. First published in Jazz Journal March 1961