Guillermo Celano Quartet: Fiction And Reality

In brief:
"The music ranges far and wide, indeed so far and widely enough to suggest a group that, if an unkind view is taken, shows a marked inability to focus"

I don’t wish to idly boast but I’m rarely bamboozled by an album, so this is something of a rarity. The music ranges far and wide, indeed so far and widely enough to suggest a group that, if an unkind view is taken, shows a marked inability to focus. A kinder view might regard the music as a shop window through which the group wants to display the whole range of its wares. If the latter is the intention, then this is a risky strategy because the attempt at all trades can result merely in the dissipation of energy.

So the restrained galumphing of Precious Metals In Exchange For Contaminated Water has the menace which is an integral part of the Belgian bands Univers Zero and Present before it breaks down into a semi-free episode only for the menace to return, albeit in a slightly more disrupted fashion.


Celano’s unaccompanied work at the outset of Fiction And Reality faintly evokes a player such as Olaf Rupp and so has the effect of distancing it from the track referred to above, not least because with the entry of the rest of the group I sensed a break so fundamental with what had gone before that the impression of discontinuity was reinforced, and all within the duration of a single track.

On a practical level Los Andes summons up the spirit of John Abercrombie, albeit with more self-conscious rigour and lack of subtlety. As he shows here, Celano’s capable of eloquence in the area of post-bop impressionism, but as it is the piece breaks down into a bass solo which again seems at odds with what has immediately preceded it, for all of Celano’s deft backing. The effect of a kind of fracture is achieved again with what comes after that solo, which in essence is an elongated “outro”.

Milonga En Temperley achieves a unity of mood, but all my cloth ear can pick out is a kind of calculated archness, as if the band felt the need for a little restraint and an overt display of unity of purpose. The track does stand out within the context of the programme it’s part of, but I found the overall discontinuity more than a little taxing.

Find out more about Guillermo Celano Quartet: Fiction And Reality at

Los Andes; Desire And Expectation; Precious Metals In Exchange For Contaminated Water; Landscape; Peru; Fiction And Reality; Milonga En Temperley; Victor Alexander Dupee (44.09)
Celano (g); Folkert Oosterbeek (p); Clemens van der Feen (b); Flin van Hemmen (d, v) Amsterdam, Netherlands, November 2019.
Trytone TT 589-082

Latest audio reviews


More from this author


Jazz Journal articles by month


Various: Happy Days Are Here Again

Covering the Great Depression years of the 30s, this wide-ranging selection consists of British and American "cheer up" recordings of songs garnered from the...

Alt. takes 05/20

One informal theme of this recently rather irregular column – for which, apologies – is misremembering or sometimes downright forgetting. I’ve recently been involved...

Ed Palermo: the big band beyond

Early on in his career Ed Palermo cut two records, Papier Mache (Vile Heifer, 1982) and Ping Pong (Pro Jazz Records, 1987) before the...

Henry Cow. The World Is A Problem

Lazy types might well have filed Henry Cow under progressive rock long before now, but in this instance as in so many others that's...

Count Basie – Through His Own Eyes

This is an excellently assembled documentary which tells us a good deal more about Basie as a person than could be gleaned from his...

JJ 04/60: In My Opinion – Eddie Harvey

'Miles Davis, although he has now become a cult, remains to me too much on one plane. I could do with a little more variety of mood, but that seems to be the way it goes today - everyone must specialize in a mood as a jazz player. Personally I think a jazz player should be able to express anything from sheer misery to proud exuberance, but they can't seem to do it these days'