Mal Waldron Trio: Free At Last (Extended Edition)

In brief:
"Waldron is a rare example of a minimalist in jazz, and his work continues to intrigue ... An epochal release, for more than one reason"

In his excellent blog, Ethan Iverson comments that on Free At Last, “everything is reduced to the drone and the riff. [Waldron’s] touch has gotten more secure and elemental… [He] wouldn’t really develop further until his death in 2002.” However, Iverson continues, “The band … is more on the B-team side, with Waldron having the best time of anyone present.”

That’s a little harsh on Swiss bassist Isla Eckinger, with whom Waldron frequently performed, and drummer Clarence Becton, who I think make up an excellent team, if not quite in the first rank.


Waldron is a rare example of a minimalist in jazz [excepting the Scandinavian legions – Ed], and his work continues to intrigue. Chris Abrahams of The Necks was deeply influenced by him. “There’s a hypnotic dimension”, he commented when I interviewed him recently. “He appeared to latch on to a phrase and work it, so that it almost hovered away from the rhythm section.” As Iverson memorably put it, “A short stutter of melody will fit anything: any harmony, any place in the beat, any tune.”

In his liner notes, Waldron described Free At Last as “My meeting with free jazz. Free jazz for me does not mean complete anarchy… You will hear me playing rhythmically instead of soloing on chord changes.” It’s groove-based and so not free in that sense; “playing rhythmically” refers to Waldron’s minimal style. The compositions are chord-based, but simple – mostly hard-driving, bluesy and modal.

The album was the very first ECM session, recorded in 1969. It was the first of three Waldron albums recorded by ECM during 1969-1971, the others being Spanish Bitch with Eberhard Weber, and The Call with the same trio as Free At Last. It’s reissued here with alternative takes of Balladina, 1-3-234, Boo and Willow Weep For Me – it’s available initially as a double-LP, and later in CD and digital formats. It’s good to have the alternative versions – those of the two ballads in particular, which are more propulsive. An epochal release, for more than one reason.

Rat Now; Balladina; 1-3-234; Rock My Soul; Willow Weep For Me; Boo; 1-3-234; Balladina; Boo; Willow Weep For Me (41.46 + 27.47)
Waldron (p); Isla Eckinger (b); Clarence Becton (d). Ludwigsburg, Germany, 24 November 1969.
ECM 779 8632 2XLP

Reader Sean Wilkie comments:

In his review of Mal Waldron’s Free At Last, your reviewer notes Ethan Iverson’s judgement of Waldron’s colleagues: “The band … is more on the B-team side…’.

He then judges Iverson’s judgement: “That’s a little harsh.”

And then judges Waldron’s band-mates to be “an excellent team, if not quite in the first rank”.

But, surely, being not quite in the first rank means being in the second rank? And isn’t that what Iverson meant by “on the B-team”?

I had the great pleasure to hear Mr Waldron playing in duo with Steve Lacy at Brecon in 1999. A very tall pianist, with fine tartan trousers. Listening to Lacy and Waldron playing Monk’s music, I felt the familiarity of the tunes giving way to the edgy rhythms of their melodies. This felt like a very direct connection to jazz history.

Andy Hamilton replies:

Apologies, I should have written “if not absolutely of the first-rank”. So my ordering of accolades is on these levels:

Excellent if not absolutely of the first-rank
Not of the first rank
Definitely B-team


Jazz Journal articles by month


Artie Shaw: Moonray

Artie and the band broadcast regularly throughout 1939 from New York’s Hotel Pennsylvania, which is no doubt why these two broadcasts from...

Still Clinging to the Wreckage 02/19

"I must confess to getting more joy from previously unissued material by Buck, Pres, Hawk, Zoot, Getz, Hodges etc. than hearing some...

Don Joseph, jazz poet /2

Another Greenwich Village venue that Don played was the Nut Club, where Phil Woods held court with Jon Eardley, Teddy Kotick, Nick...

Jim Marshall: Show Me The Picture: Images And Stories From A Photography Legend

Jim Marshall (1936-2010) is largely known for his images of the jazz greats and rock stars of the 60s and 70s. This...

Motherless Brooklyn

Actor Edward Norton secured the rights to Jonathan Lethern’s best-selling novel Motherless Brooklyn on publication in 1999. Exactly 20 years later he...