Advertisement
Advertisement

JJ 08/90: Bob Belden Ensemble: Treasure Island

Thirty years ago Bruce Crowther noted that university-educated big bands were precise but not always soulful. First published in Jazz Journal 1990

Until recently, the vast number of American university students flooding out of places like East­man and UCLA and North Texas State had only limited places to go if they wanted to play in big bands: Kenton, Herman, Rich, Ferguson. Now they haven’t even those outlets (pace Maynard) but some of them have not lost the desire and turn up in rehearsal bands and, as here, in a band formed and led by an NTSU gra­duate.

Belden left university in 1978, went into the Herman band and formed this group early in 1989. His sidemen include men (I hesitate to use the term ‘veter­ans’) who have worked with Mul­ligan, Akiyoshi, Blakey, Ibrahim, Lewis, the aforementioned Her­man, Ferguson et al, and a string of symphony gigs where their thorough musical grounding and undoubted technical expertise stood them in good stead.

Advertisement

On this set there is no lack of brilliant playing even if, as so often is the case with the university bands and, dare I say it, some of the latterday recordings by Woody and Buddy and the others, there is sometimes an absence of heart and soul.

Some of the music here is familiar (Zawinul’s Directions, Shorter’s Face, Spencer Wil­liams’s Basin Street). Most is new with the long suite of particular interest as an example of the directions being taken by many young musicians today.

In all, this is interesting rather than ex­citing music played with preci­sion and skill rather than relaxed swing. If you like the university bands and late Kenton, Rich and Herman you will probably like this one; others should hear it first. Good sound and excellent playing time.

Discography
Treasure Island Suite: Treasure Island, Deja Vu, The Treasure, Rites Of Passage, The Goodbye, The Voyage Home; Directions; Face On The Barroom Floor; Miss Razeau; Country Corn­flakes; Love From My Heart; Basin Street Blues; Pas De Deux (77.08)
Jim Powell, Tim Hagans (t/flh); John Fedchock (tb); George Moran (btb); Peter Reit (frh); Carl Klienstrauber (tu); Chuck Wilson (cl/f); Mike Migliore (as/f/picc); Ron Kozak (bcl/af); Bob Belden (ts); Tim Ries, Craig Handy (ts/ss); Glenn Wilson (bs); Marc Cohen (p/syn); Jay Anderson (b); Jeff Hirshfield (d); New York City 12, 13 August 1989.
(SunnysideSSC1041D)

Latest audio reviews

Advertisement

More from this author

Advertisement

Jazz Journal articles by month

Advertisement

Maynard Ferguson: The Lost Tapes Bonus

Throughout a long career trumpet virtuoso Maynard Ferguson fronted a number of very fine big bands and none better perhaps than the one heard...
Advertisement

Obituary: Duffy Jackson

There was never any doubt that Duffy Jackson would become a jazz musician, specifically a drummer. The son of a famous jazz bassist, Chubby...
Advertisement

Trevor Watts: ‘What I hear today seems to be a lot of cloning’

Now 82, saxophonist Trevor Watts retains the same passion for creating music and collaborating with other players as he did when he led pioneering...
Advertisement

Ugly Beauty: Jazz In The 21st Century

Phil Freeman in his thorough survey of 21st century jazz (so far) is with fellow writer Stanley Crouch in believing that it's no longer...
Advertisement

Symphonies in Black: Duke Ellington shorts at the Barbican, London

Back in the day, when you and I were young, Maggie, and your local Essoldo offered not one, but two feature films, a newsreel,...
Advertisement

JJ 08/80: Allan Holdsworth & Gordon Beck – The Things You See

Two outstanding musicians do not always make a good duo combination. Here they do. The only adverse comment one must make is that such...